Batman: The Long Halloween review



Why'd they put Two-Face on the cover? Way to spoil the ending, guys.

Batman:  The Long Halloween is a graphic novel (trade paperback?) that compiles the thirteen issue limited series of the same name.  Writer Jeph Loeb and artist Tim Sale worked in the continuity of Batman:  Year One, created by writer Frank Miller, illustrated by David Mazzucchelli, colorist Richmond Lewis, and lettering by Todd Klein, although Long Halloween is superior to Year One in just about every way possible, although I would say Sale and Mazzucchelli’s artistic skills are fairly even.  It’s not enough to say that Long Halloween is better than Year One; I have to make it clear that Long Halloween is probably the best comic book limited series I’ve ever read, and even that’s not giving it enough credit, because these days, Marvel and DC push out zillions of awful limited series every year, to the point where I had to stop buying them all together – see Batman Odyssey and Siege for examples of this.

If you read Batman:  Year One, then you should be right at home with Long Halloween, but I wouldn’t call Year One required reading by any stretch of the imagination.  In fact, I don’t have much to say about Year One – at least, I don’t have much praise to heap on it.  I assumed it was going to be an origin story, but it really isn’t; essentially, we just see a young Batman who makes a lot more mistakes then we’re accustomed to seeing Batman make.  Details and character development are not delivered to the audience in abundance, and ultimately, the book damaged my opinion of Frank Miller.  Essentially, Long Halloween grabs the undeveloped mob characters from Year One and develops them.  (If you’re interested in an origin story for Batman, you may as well go watch Batman Begins again – which borrows from Year One, but fleshes out the characters (especially Batman) in ways that Year One never even attempted.

Perhaps the greatest contributor to Long Halloween was Mark Waid, who did wonders for Captain America after Mark Gruenwald’s 10 year reign of terror ended with his untimely death.  Waid suggested that Loeb work with Two-Face’s origin, and the rest, as they say, is history. There is a ton of Long Halloween in The Dark Knight’s script, and frankly, The Dark Knight is one of the greatest action movies of all time.  But Long Halloween is more than a template for The Dark Knight; it’s very much its own story.

Although Long Halloween is said to focus on a younger Batman than we’re accustomed to seeing, it’s not really true, at least not in my mind.  Batman is presented as the character we all know and love, it’s just that certain events haven’t come to pass yet in the Batman time line:  Gordon is still Captain Gordon, not commissioner yet; Two-Face is still Harvey Dent, which is a major plot thread in the story; Dick Grayson is presumably on tour with his parents and the circus as he doesn’t make an appearance…  Yet, nearly every major Batman villain is already established and presented in the story without explanation:  the Joker, Poison Ivy, The Riddler, The Mad Hatter, The Scarecrow, Calendar Man and Catwoman are all in Long Halloween.  I don’t have any problem with this, and the use of the Rogue Gallery is brilliantly done here, but I wouldn’t say we’re anywhere near the beginning of the Batman story.

batman long halloween bruce wayne

"I believe in America - Gotham City. I meant Gotham."

One curious bit about Long Halloween is it’s over abundance of homages to The Godfather.  The very first page of Long Halloween is Bruce Wayne saying, “I believe in Gotham City,” to Carmine Falcone, just as we see Bonasera say to Vito in the first moments of The Godfather.  Falcone wears a similar suit to Vito Corleone, and his nephew is getting married, just like the first scene in The Godfather, except it’s Vito’s daughter who is getting married there.  Pages later, after a shootout in Flacone’s office, he says, “In my home.  On my nephew’s wedding day,” similar to Micheal’s reaction to his attempted assassination in Godfather II:  “In my home!  In my bedroom, where my wife sleeps!  Where my children come to play with their toys.”  The homages don’t really end there, but then, when you’re writing about gangsters and you choose to make allusions to the Godfather…  it’s kind of a joke, but its well done, but it might also be viewed as cheating character development; you just immediately associate these characters with the characters from The Godfather…  but it’s original enough to keep you interested.

For the most part, Long Halloween is a story about Batman, Gordon and Dent teaming up together to take down the mob, so you can easily see how the The Dark Knight they borrowed this angle.  The movie adapts a scene where Dent and Batman burn down a warehouse full of mob money as opposed to The Joker doing so in the film.  There are scenes up on the roof top with Batman, Gordon and Dent talking and planning (similar scenes appear in The Dark Knight), but their investigations and arrests provide little in the way of results.  A killer emerges who targets the mob, always committing it’s murder on a Holiday (and the press so names the killer ‘Holiday’) and leaving both the murder weapon and a token that represents the particular holiday, like the jack-o-lantern that is left with the first victim, who was killed on Halloween.  Wash, rinse, and repeat.

Yeah, the story is a bit repetitive, yet still engaging.  I’d say it was a mistake to force 13 issues (I did say force… why do 12 issues when you can do 13?  The Poison Ivy plot thread is as silly as the Scarecrow thread is useless) and given that I read the trade paper back (Graphic novel?  Can I use those terms interchangeably or what?) rather than the individual issues as they came out once a month, I had to deal with quite a bit of reintroduction that could have been easily edited out, but wasn’t.  I think I read that “Carmine Falcone is Gotham City’s


The tux, and the moment, is very Godfather.

Untouchable Crime Lord” about 20 times.  Although they’ve packaged all 13 issues together, no effort was made to have it move seamlessly like a novel with chapters, and I guess that was intentional – they dropped in some cover art before each issue started, and I was glad to have it, but they could have stuck them all in the back and edited it together at least a little bit.

While I wouldn’t say that Batman:  The Long Halloween is perfect, there is no doubt that it’s great.  I loved it, and I look forward to reading it again – I guarantee you that by the end, you both WILL and WILL NOT have correctly identified the Holiday killer.  Riddle that out!  If you like The Godfather and Batman, Long Halloween is a no brainer, and even if you only like one of the two, I sitll recommend you pick it up.

NOTE: The girlfriend that gets you a graphic novel (trade paperback?) for Valentine’s Day really understands and accepts you!


This slideshow requires JavaScript.

More Batman at

About Jamie Insalaco

Jamie Insalaco is the author of, and editor in chief of

Posted on March 16, 2011, in Batman, comic book reviews and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 6 Comments.

  1. First of all man, I’ve been on the receiving end of countless birthdays which included Graphic Novels, author signed collected issues of certain mini series, special edition DVDs… and yes, on two different occasions, a Wii AND a Playstation 3!!
    So I fully agree and appreciate your GF getting you. I married mine… the comic/movies/games were obviously not the reasons… but they played a big part. 😉

    Moving on: I sort of disagree with your BATMAN: YEAR ONE assessment, however I think that has less to do with your like/dislike of it and more to do with the quality of the work produced at the time. I actually find it hard NOT to agree with some of your points about YEAR ONE. I completely agree that a lot of character development was under done, Batman was very sloppy, and even the mob characters were kind of cliche. But I actually liked seeing a flawed Batman making retarded mistakes that you’re more likely to see in other teen-superhero stories than a Batman one. The lack of finesse and any sort of style in his abilities is what I found a departure and a true origin (as was intended, actually implemented or not is up for debate) similar to how we got a crude and brute forced Bond in CASINO ROYALE. I think that was what appealed to me. Also the roaming through prostitute ridden streets and taking ass kickings was cool to see, especially considering those were the first times we saw Bruce Wayne in that state (BATMAN BEGINS still being a while away.)

    THE LONG HALLOWEEN was an awesome book. Oh, and OGN (Original Graphic Novel) refers to stories released only in TPB (Trade Paperback) or HC (Hardcover) format… where as a Graphic Novel is more the general term used to describe collected volumes of single issues. So yes, you can use both interchangeably.

    I loved the LONG HALLOWEEN and actually, loved everything from Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale like BATMAN: DARK VICTORY and I think there was another one of theirs which was a compilation of three specials?

    • Yep, a good woman is hard to find!

      I guess my problem with Year One (and it’s my problem, not really Frank Miller’s) is that I just assumed I was going to see more of how one trains to become batman… Where does one get a utility belt? Can Bruce Wayne so, or does Alfred handle the costume? At first, I was pleased to watch Batman get his ass kicked, but it got a bit redundant for me. I can hardly remember it (and I just read it recently), while I wrote my Long Halloween review from memory… yeah, that’s the best way I can put it – Year One just wasn’t very memorable.

      However, I did like Casino Royal a lot – I haven’t seen every Bond movie (not even close), but that one certainly stands out for me.

      I guess I just prefer Jeph Loeb and Mark Waid to most writers… I’ve also found myself to be quite the Ed Brubaker fan. I think my interest in Grant Morrison was a passing one; the only Batman book I’m reading now (Batman Confidential) is written by Marc Gugenheim. I do like Frank Miller a lot, too – especially his work on Daredevil. I haven’t gotten around to Dark Victory yet, which I believe is further down the timeline as Robin is in that – yes, i believe Loeb also wrote something called Catwoman: When in Rome that I also have not read yet.

      Thanks for helping me out with the whole TPB/Trade Paperback, HC/Hardcover, Graphic Novel thing!

      Thanks for commenting!

  2. I know, and you’re right, it wasn’t that memorable. But I’m glad it got fleshed out more in BATMAN BEGINS.

    I became a fan of Waid after KINGDOM COME, which was the first ever GN that I read, after like a decade’s long hiatus from comics. Morrison to me is very trippy and wierd, for the sake of being wierd. I did like BATMAN: R.I.P. and love what he’s doing with the current BATMAN INC. other than that, I found FINAL CRISIS to be ass.

    No worries… take care man. Check out my Blogs when you get some time. Doing a Web Comic of my own + have some reviews on my other Blog.

    • Agreed – Batman Begins was what I’d been waiting for… there were little glimpses of Batman’s training in Batman The Animated Series that interested me, and I think Begins gave us the best look at how one trains to be Batman

      ‘weird for the sake of being weird’ is as good a description of Morrison as I could come up with. Did you read The Return of Bruce Wayne? I wrote about that toward the middle of the series… that limited series just didn’t do anything for me, for a lot of reasons, and I was getting tired of his of their cover art, as they seemed to be working to assemble their All Batman Village People Review. Very ASSY! =)

      I look forward to checking out your stuff!

      thanks for dropping by and commenting – laters =)

  1. Pingback: Speculating on the plot of Dark Knight Rises |

  2. Pingback: The Godfather (movie review) |

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: